PTDC

Charity Comparison Tool

Find the best organization for your vehicle donation.

Top Matches for You

Habitat for Humanity Cars for Homes logo
Community

Habitat for Humanity Cars for Homes

Transparency
All 50 States

Pros

  • Proceeds stay in your local community
  • High financial transparency rating
  • Accepts almost all vehicle types
  • Free and fast towing

Cons

  • Cannot guarantee the final sale price of the vehicle
  • Does not accept vehicles with major liens
Goodwill Car Donation Program logo
Community

Goodwill Car Donation Program

Transparency
All 50 States

Pros

  • 82% of revenue goes directly to programs — among the highest efficiency in the industry
  • Proceeds typically benefit workforce development in your local community
  • Accepts virtually all vehicle types and conditions, including non-running vehicles
  • Free towing nationwide with pickup typically within 24-48 hours
  • 90/100 Charity Navigator score reflects strong financial transparency
  • Well-established, trusted brand with over 3,000 locations across North America

Cons

  • Some regional vehicle donations are processed through third-party platforms, which may reduce net proceeds
  • Local chapter efficiency can vary — some areas have faster processing times than others
  • Vehicle sale price is determined at auction and cannot be guaranteed in advance
St. Jude Children's Research Hospital logo
Children

St. Jude Children's Research Hospital

Transparency
All 50 States

Pros

  • 95/100 Charity Navigator score — one of the highest-rated charities in the United States
  • 79% of revenue reaches programs — strong efficiency for a hospital/research institution
  • Pediatric cancer research has improved childhood cancer survival rates from 20% to over 80% since 1962
  • No child is ever turned away or charged for treatment — all families receive care free of cost
  • Strong brand recognition and decades of donor trust
  • Free towing nationwide for running and non-running vehicles

Cons

  • Vehicle donation processing is handled by third-party partners, not St. Jude directly
  • Proceeds go to a national fund, not a geographically local program
  • Like all vehicle donation programs, auction proceeds are typically 15-30% below private-party KBB value

Detailed Side-by-Side Comparison

Charity Name
Cause
Transparency
Picks Up Same DaySells CarsRepairs & GivesAction
Habitat for Humanity Cars for Homes
Community
5/5 Stars
View Details
Goodwill Car Donation Program
Community
5/5 Stars
View Details
St. Jude Children's Research Hospital
Children
5/5 Stars
View Details
World Vision
Children
5/5 Stars
View Details
Goodwill Industries
Community
4/5 Stars
View Details
Make-A-Wish America (Wheels for Wishes)
Children
4/5 Stars
View Details
American Cancer Society
Health
4/5 Stars
View Details
The Salvation Army
Community
4/5 Stars
View Details
National Kidney Foundation
Health
4/5 Stars
View Details
St. Jude Children's Research Hospital
Children
4/5 Stars
View Details
Local Food Banks
Community
4/5 Stars
View Details
Wheels for Wishes
Children
4/5 Stars
View Details
Local Nonprofits Car Donation Guide
Community
4/5 Stars
View Details
Vehicles for Veterans
Veterans
3/5 Stars
View Details
Kars4Kids
Children
3/5 Stars
View Details
DAV (Disabled American Veterans)
Veterans
3/5 Stars
View Details
Breast Cancer Research Foundation
Health
3/5 Stars
View Details
Toys for Tots
Children
3/5 Stars
View Details
Religious Organizations
General
3/5 Stars
View Details

Frequently Asked Questions